SSAS Cache Isn't Making Cents

I stole the pun from my Business Analyst, Mr. John Seiler Now on to my issue - when SSAS caches the value for my [Actual] measure, it seems to do so based on the results of the first query that requests that coordinate. In this particular cube, there's bunches of tiny fractions and depending on how you slice it, it aggregates a little different. This is a fun problem in itself, but the part that drives me (and the Finance department) crazy is that if you go and slice on something OTHER than that first query that created the cache, the values they see don't always add up to the "Grand Total" in Excel - aka. "All"